The Expanding Meaning of “Other Cause”: Support Entitlement Beyond the Age of Majority

I proceed to be amazed by the velocity with which judicial interpretation of household legislation statutes evolves, and the way that evolution undermines what little certainty these statutes present to separating mother and father. As household legislation attorneys will recall, part 2(1) of the Divorce Act supplies that:

“Baby of the marriage” means a baby of two spouses or former spouses who, at the materials time … is the age of majority or over and beneath their cost however unable, by cause of sickness, incapacity or different trigger, to withdraw from their cost or to acquire the requirements of life.

As soon as upon a time, questions on the entitlement of grownup kids to learn from the ongoing cost of youngster assist beneath the act usually known as for a reasonably simple evaluation, regardless of a smattering of pre- and post-Pointers instances to the opposite. Is the youngster in full-time attendance at a post-secondary establishment aimed towards a remunerative profession? No? Alright then, does the youngster undergo from an sickness or incapacity of such gravity that they’re unable to be or change into self-sufficient? No? Effectively then, I’m sorry however that’s it for assist.

The legislation, of course, developed from that earlier, relatively parsimonious, place pretty rapidly. The requirement that the course of research be geared toward a wise profession was the first to go, a boon to these of us who had foolishly chosen to review philosophy, and was adopted briefly order by the requirement that the youngster be enrolled on full-time foundation and by the limitation of assist to the quantity of years minimally required to finish the youngster’s chosen tutorial program. Entitlement was subsequent prolonged to kids taking a spot 12 months or two after highschool, to those that had interrupted a program of research to work or journey, after which to these with merely an inexpensive plan to proceed their post-secondary training sooner or later in the future.

The current Alberta Courtroom of Queen’s Bench determination in Okay.M.R. v I.W.R., 2020 ABQB 77 highlights developments in the legislation additional increasing entitlement beneath the nebulous thought of “different trigger” which proceed to undermine the previously strong presumption that kids over the age of majority don’t have any proper to youngster assist (see, for instance, Geran v Geran, 2011 SKCA 55 or Szitas v Szitas, 2012 ONSC 1548). On this case, the youngster lived with the payor however modified houses to stay with the recipient two years after reaching the age of majority, and continued to stay with the recipient till the time of the listening to, when he was 22 years outdated. The recipient argued that the youngster, who was unemployed and had dropped out of college a couple of months earlier than transferring in along with her, continued to be entitled to youngster assist on the foundation of undiagnosed psychological well being dysfunction.

Though the eminent trial decide Justice Rodney Jerke held that

“[36] Absent a medical prognosis and medical proof substantiating [the recipient’s] declare that [the child] suffers from anxiousness, post-traumatic stress dysfunction and/or one other psychological sickness, and extra importantly, absent any medical proof that his anxiousness or a psychological sickness considerably impairs his capability to return to college or to acquire full-time employment, Canadian case legislation doesn’t assist a discovering that [the child] isn’t capable of withdraw from his mother and father’ cost or to amass ‘the necessaries of life’, whether or not on account of an sickness, incapacity or ‘different trigger.’ …”

he nonetheless undertook a evaluation of different potential grounds of persevering with entitlement, noting trial and appellate authority supporting the proposition that the phrase “different trigger” in the Divorce Act’s definition of “youngster of the marriage” is to be interpreted broadly (see Baker v Baker, (1994) 2 RFL (4th) 147 (ABQB), Gamache v Gamache, 1999 ABQB 313 and Olson v Olson, 2003 ABCA 56). The smattering of instances I discussed earlier has its roots on this strategy to the definition and deserves a better look earlier than I return to Okay.M.R.

In Gamache, the court docket noticed that whereas mother and father don’t “have an indefinite obligation to assist a baby who’s attending college or is unemployed or underemployed,” mother and father do have an obligation to assist grownup kids who’re unable to supply for themselves via “an inexpensive transition interval.” In Weir v Weir, (1986) 1 RFL (3d) 438 (BCSC), the court docket held that dependence arising from a “poor job market” certified grownup kids for assist, a conclusion that was expanded in Bruehler v Bruehler, (1985) 49 RFL (2nd) 44 (BCCA) to incorporate “a state of [economic] melancholy in a province.” In Smith v Smith, (1987) 12 RFL (3d) 50 (BCSC), the court docket held {that a} 20-year-old unemployed highschool dropout with aspirations of a profession in modelling continued to qualify as a baby of the marriage, as a result of of a “considerably depressed financial system.”

These and different selections led Justice Jerke to counsel that “it could be that the Courts are recognizing a broader social actuality as considerations the idea of ‘youngster of the marriage’,” and cite the judgment in Brear v Brear, 2019 ABCA 419 in sturdy assist of this conclusion:

“[51] There are few kids, whether or not or not from separated or divorced households, who’re economically self-sufficient on their 18th or 19th birthday or in the month they full highschool. However until a baby is getting into post-secondary research, the widespread actuality is youngster assist obligations of the payor mother or father typically stop on or shut to those dates. …

“[52] Certainly, Statistics Canada census information reveals that whereas extra younger adults could also be transferring again dwelling than in the previous, a good better proportion are staying of their mother and father’ dwelling longer. The share of younger adults aged 20 to 34 dwelling with a minimum of one mother or father elevated from 33.1% in 2006 to 34.7% in 2016. For these aged 20 to 24, the proportion ‘co-residing’ with their mother and father rose from 58.3% in 2001 to 62.6% in 2016. For these aged 20 to 24 and dwelling with their mother and father in 2011, 69% reported they’d by no means left their mother and father’ dwelling.”

Whereas Weir, Bruehler and Smith targeted on financial situations, Brear takes observe of the up to date pattern towards delayed maturation amongst at present’s younger adults, and the delay of their independence which logically follows. In keeping with Statistics Canada, the quantity of 20- to 24-years-olds nonetheless dwelling with a mother or father climbed by virtually 20% between 1981 and 2011, whereas the quantity of 25- to 29-year-olds dwelling with a mother or father climbed by about 15%:

Likewise, the quantity of girls having kids usually decreased in the age 20 to 29 group between 1993 and 2013, however elevated dramatically in the age 35 to 44 group:

Though Justice Jerke finally held that the youngster in Okay.M.R. ceased to qualify as a baby of the marriage –

“[44] … there is no such thing as a proof that the present social and financial situations are depressed to such an extent that [the child] couldn’t have obtained full-time employment, in Alberta or elsewhere, throughout the final two years. It isn’t unattainable to discover a job in Alberta with no college or faculty diploma. The situations might justify an inexpensive transitionary interval of youngster assist after [the child] eased attending college full-time. However, on the proof right here it’s clear that [the child] has made no efforts to search out full-time employment, and even any employment, since he completed his first 12 months of college… This isn’t a state of affairs the place an grownup youngster tried to discover a fulltime job, but it surely took her or him a number of months to take action. [The child] has not tried in any respect.”

– his evaluation of the case legislation suggests a softening in trial courts’ strategy to grownup kids and considerably of an assault on the proposition, expressed in D.B.S. v S.R.G., 2006 SCC 37, that:

“[89] … An grownup, i.e., one who’s over the age of majority and isn’t dependent, isn’t the kind of particular person for whom Parliament envisioned youngster assist orders being made. … Baby assist is for youngsters of the marriage, not adults who used to have that standing.”

As the court docket commented in Brear, “How does this coverage consideration align with the social actuality that kids’s financial self-sufficiency is delayed and one mother or father faces a disproportionate monetary burden? Respectfully, it doesn’t.” I’m inclined to agree.

The “broader social actuality” Justice Jerke references consists of not simply depressed financial circumstances and the acknowledgment of a generally essential transition interval between emancipation and independence, however the total delay in maturation of at present’s younger adults demonstrated by the rising quantity of grownup kids who stay at dwelling, the rising age of girls having kids and the rising age of folks’s first marriage, to say nothing of the lowering worth of undergraduate levels and the corresponding development in post-graduate enrolment.

If these demographic traits proceed, I count on that the presumption towards the entitlement of grownup kids to assist expressed in Geran, Szitas and D.B.S. will proceed to erode. Counsel ought to not leap to the conclusion that grownup kids who’re neither disabled nor in enrolled in post-secondary research stop to qualify as “kids of the marriage,” however pursue a deeper contextual inquiry into the explanation why a baby is unable to withdraw from their mother and father’ cost or acquire the requirements of life.

The Expanding Meaning of “Other Cause”: Support Entitlement Beyond the Age of Majority

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.